Theory Section
  • Info
    • Theory Events ASA Virtual Engagement Meeting
    • Bylaws
    • Section officers
    • Announcements
    • For Students
    • Junior Theorist Symposium
  • Newsletters
    • Current Newsletter Online
    • PDF Archives
  • Awards
    • Awards Overview
    • How to Submit
    • Theory Prize
    • Junior Theorist Award
    • Best Student Paper Award
    • Coser Award
  • Resources
    • New Publications
    • Theory Journals
    • Teaching Theory
    • Theory Syllabi
    • Theory Webpages

Perspectives
A NEWSLETTER OF THE ASA THEORY SECTION


Dissertation Spotlight - Sam Hobson

12/15/2021

5 Comments

 
Picture

Sam Hobson
​University of Michigan

My dissertation is about the ways in which structural power and oppression are replicated through acts of social justice and what that means for our attempts at social change. My work is with the food justice movement in NYC. Practices of food justice include urban agriculture, food education, and farmers’ markets. Although food justice is grounded in a structural analysis of race, class, and food, and incorporates an antiracist framework, my ethnographic research unveiled instances of structural oppression being created through food justice practices. These instances were the result of movement action of both white activists and non-white activists of high SES. So, my dissertation asks, how are the intentionally anti-racist movement practices of structurally powerful food justice activists reproducing structural oppression? ​
I argue that, despite our best intentions, social justice has the ability to operate as a mechanism of structural domination. This is because, in its current formulation, it tends to be a social practice that allows structurally powerful people to replicate not only their relationship to structural power but also that of the marginalized population they’re impacting by allowing the former to affect the choices, experiences, and life chances of the latter (Einspahr 2010; Young 1990). My dissertation is a deconstruction of this phenomenon through a multi-level analysis of the relationship between the structural, behavioral, and schematic processes behind it. I am currently triangulating the ethnographic observation I’ve conducted with interviews of activists in my study, developing a comparative analysis that examines how this relationship between the structural, behavioral, and schematic varies by the intersectional identities of movement activists. Scholarship that asks how social movements backfire tend to offer organizational explanations. However, I argue that our theoretical focus needs to be towards activists’ social positions and cultural frameworks, requiring an incorporation of intersectionality and critical race theory into social movement scholarship. Such a marriage will illuminate the overlooked the heterogeneity that is implicated in seemingly homogenous movement actions. It will also unveil the complexity with which structural power operates through social movement action and affects the formation, dynamics, and outcomes of social movements. 

I use structural domination scholarship and Black Feminist Thought to explicate this. This project will contribute an intersectional analytic of power to social movement scholarship and a focus towards social movements as a site of knowledge production to critical scholarship. My ultimate goal for this project is to develop a power analysis that can be applied to myriad situations of justice, reform, and anti-racism. I believe that such an analysis is essential for public policy, nonprofits, DEI initiatives, social movement activism, and social justice so that justice and reform work isn’t just another way to obfuscate the perpetuation of oppression. 
​

Citations:
Einspahr, Jennifer. 2010. “Structural Domination and Structural Freedom: A Feminist Perspective.” Feminist Review 94(1):1–19.

Young, Iris Marion. 1990. Justice and the Politics of Difference. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

Sam Hobson is a PhD candidate at the University of Michigan who lives in New Haven, Connecticut. My areas of research interests include race, power, intersectionality, and social change. I expect to graduate Fall 2023. 

5 Comments
shareit link
3/24/2022 10:48:42 am

ks for sharing the article, and more importantly, your personal experience mindfully using our emotions as data about our inner state and kno sdcwing when it’zddc cds better to de-escalate by taking a time out are great tools. Appreciate you reading and sharing your story since I can certainly relate and I think others can to

Reply
mxplayer link
3/24/2022 11:12:24 am

e article, and more importantly, your personal experience mindfully using our emotions as data about our inner state and kno sdcwing when it’zddc cds better to de-escalate by taking a time out are great tools. Appreciate you reading and sharing your story since I can certainly relate and I think others can to

Reply
Jessica Smith
5/3/2022 10:15:15 am

Bitcoin investment has changed my life because I invested my bitcoin with Mr Anderson Carl. He is a professional trader and he help me trade my bitcoin and he can also help you. My first investment with Anderson Carl, I profited up to $2,600 with my investment of $200 in 7 days, Looking into this week as well, what have you planned to achieve? Why not take that step now and contact Anderson Carl on whatsapp: +1(252)285-2093 Email:(andersoncarlassettrade@gmail.com)I advice you shouldn't hesitate He's great.

Reply
Jessica Smith
5/3/2022 10:15:23 am

Bitcoin investment has changed my life because I invested my bitcoin with Mr Anderson Carl. He is a professional trader and he help me trade my bitcoin and he can also help you. My first investment with Anderson Carl, I profited up to $2,600 with my investment of $200 in 7 days, Looking into this week as well, what have you planned to achieve? Why not take that step now and contact Anderson Carl on whatsapp: +1(252)285-2093 Email:(andersoncarlassettrade@gmail.com)I advice you shouldn't hesitate He's great.

Reply
Find Long Distance Movers link
5/9/2022 02:59:59 am

Interstate moves tend to be more in-depth moves than local moves. Generally speaking, an interstate move is any move that crosses state lines. This means that, even if the move is going just a few miles but is in another state, then it is considered an interstate move. Interstate moves fall under federal regulations and as a result typically cost more than a local move. Be wary of local movers who claim they do interstate moves and make sure they have the proper licenses and insurances to do so.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    summer 2022 Content

    Letter from the Chair: "Sociology From/Of Latin America"

    "Migration Myopias and Insights from the Global South"

    "Cannibalizing the Northern Environmental Justice Perspective"

    "Plurinationality as an Idea and a Reality in 21st Century Bolivia, Ecuador, and Chile"

    "Feminism at a Crossroads: Key Takeaways from Latin America"

    "Debt, Greed, and Disasters: For a Plausible Study of Puerto Rico and its Systemic Risk"

    "The State of the Canon: Sociological Theory Syllabi in the United States"

    Emerging Theorist Spotlight: Birgan Gokmenoglu

    Emerging Theorist Spotlight: Abigail Cary Moore

    Theory Section Awards

    Recent Publications

    EDITORS

    Vasfiye Toprak
    ​Abigail Cary Moore
    Anne Taylor​

    Archives

    August 2022
    December 2021
    July 2021
    December 2020
    August 2020
    December 2019
    July 2019
    January 2019
    June 2018
    December 2017
    December 2016
    June 2016
    April 2016
    December 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    February 2015
    December 2014

    Categories

    All
    ASA Meetings
    Awards
    Big Data
    Book Review
    CFP
    Conference Recap
    Dissertation Spotlight
    Interactive
    JTS
    JTS2014
    Letter From The Editors
    News & Notes
    Notes From The Chair
    Pragmatism
    Prizes
    Recent Publications
    Teaching
    The Classics
    Winners Dialogue

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly